How to Harmonize the Harmonic Minor Scale for Better Chords
The harmonic minor scale exists specifically to bridge the gap between melodic fluidity and functional harmonic strength. By raising the seventh degree, you gain a leading tone that pulls toward the tonic, but you also create a jagged augmented second interval. Balancing this interval requires careful voice leading, as the resulting chords often demand specific resolutions that differ significantly from the smoother, more predictable natural minor scale.
Quick facts
| Chord Degree | Quality | Function |
|---|---|---|
| i | Minor | Tonic |
| V | Major | Dominant |
| vii° | Diminished | Leading tone |
| III+ | Augmented | Mediant |
What are the primary triads derived from the harmonic minor scale?
Building triads on the harmonic minor scale yields a specific set of primary and secondary chords that define its unique harmonic identity. The tonic (i) is minor, while the dominant (V) becomes major due to the raised seventh degree. This major V chord is the engine of the scale, providing a strong pull toward the tonic that the natural minor scale lacks. You also gain the mediant (III+) and the leading-tone (vii°) chords, which add tension and color.
For example, in A harmonic minor, the V chord is E major, which contains the G-sharp necessary to resolve to A minor. A nuance to keep in mind is the iv chord, which remains minor. While it functions as a subdominant, placing it before the V chord creates a classic, reliable progression that anchors the tonality despite the scale's inherent instability.
How do the seventh chords built from the harmonic minor scale differ from those of the natural minor scale?
The harmonic minor scale produces a fully diminished seventh chord (vii°7) on the seventh degree, whereas the natural minor scale only yields a minor seventh chord there. This specific adjustment introduces a tension-filled, symmetrical structure that allows for more intense chromatic resolution back to the tonic chord.
Why is the augmented second interval between the sixth and seventh degrees significant for chord construction?
The augmented second interval between the sixth and seventh degrees creates a distinct, exotic flavor often associated with Middle Eastern or neoclassical styles. When constructing chords, this interval forces the harmonic structure to accommodate a wide gap, which can make smooth voice leading difficult. If you build a chord that spans this interval, such as the iv chord or the ii° chord, the proximity of the sixth degree to the raised seventh creates a sense of unresolved longing.
For instance, the ii° chord (B-D-F in A harmonic minor) is a diminished triad that feels inherently unstable. An exception occurs when composers choose to flatten the sixth degree in passing, effectively turning the scale into melodic minor to smooth out the interval. This choice prioritizes linear flow over vertical harmonic consistency, showing that the augmented second is a tool to be used only when you want that specific, jagged tension.
How does the leading tone in the harmonic minor scale influence functional harmony and cadences?
The raised leading tone creates a strong gravitational pull toward the tonic, enabling authentic cadences that define minor-key stability. By transforming the minor v chord into a major V chord, the scale establishes a clear hierarchy where the dominant demands resolution. Many listeners assume that the leading tone must always resolve upward by a half-step to the tonic, but in practice, you can occasionally drop it down to the sixth degree in an inner voice to create a deceptive or softened cadence.
What are the most common voice-leading techniques used to resolve the diminished triad in this scale?
Resolving the diminished triad requires careful management of the leading tone to prevent jarring dissonance.
- Root motion: Move the root of the diminished triad up by a half-step to the tonic to satisfy the ear's expectation for closure.
- Voice exchange: Swap the notes between the bass and the upper voices to allow the leading tone to descend into a stable chord tone.
- Contrary motion: Direct the outer voices in opposite directions so that the dissonance expands outward into a consonant interval like a perfect fifth or octave.
- Preparation: Precede the diminished chord with a stable tonic or subdominant to provide a clear harmonic context before the tension peaks.
How can secondary dominants be applied to the chords of the harmonic minor scale?
Yes, secondary dominants can be applied by raising the third of any chord to create a temporary dominant function. For example, applying a V/iv in A minor introduces a D-sharp, which creates a strong, classical-style push toward the D minor subdominant chord.
What are the characteristic chord progressions associated with the harmonic minor tonality?
Typical progressions in this tonality rely on the V chord to emphasize the raised seventh degree and resolve the scale's inherent tension.
- i-iv-V-i: This standard sequence uses the major dominant to provide a clear, traditional sense of finality.
- i-ii°-V-i: The inclusion of the diminished ii° chord adds a darker, more chromatic color before the V chord arrives.
- i-III+-iv-V: This progression utilizes the augmented mediant to introduce a surprising, modern-sounding harmonic shift before returning to the familiar.
- V-VI-V: Using the VI chord as a deceptive resolution for the V chord creates a dramatic, unexpected pause in the harmonic flow.
How does the inclusion of the raised seventh degree affect the quality of the mediant chord?
The raised seventh degree transforms the mediant chord from a standard major triad into an augmented triad, creating a highly unstable and dissonant sonority.
| Chord | Root | Third | Fifth |
|---|---|---|---|
| Major III | 1 | 3 | 5 |
| Augmented III+ | 1 | 3 | #5 |
Use these intervals to contrast the stability of the tonic with the intense, shimmering tension of the augmented mediant.
What people often get wrong
- Ignoring the augmented second. Composers often treat the scale like natural minor, missing the chance to use the raised seventh for a strong V-i cadence.
- Overusing the augmented triad. Placing the III+ chord in a weak position can sound jarring; use it sparingly to add color rather than as a structural anchor.
- Neglecting voice leading. Because of the diminished intervals, failing to resolve leading tones properly leads to awkward, disjointed harmonic movement.
Refining Your Minor Key Progressions
Experiment with placing the dominant chord immediately before the tonic to hear how the raised seventh creates a sense of completion. Focus your practice on resolving the diminished vii° chord to the i chord to master the most common harmonic tension in this scale.